Trophies

One of the things on my bucket list was to reorganize the AtWar trophy page. For those of you who don't know the page is available to moderators and admins to add, remove and give trophies. Some of you probably don't know this but I've been doing this on and off for the past year and now I need your opinion.

Most if not all trophies have been arranged into categories. Some categories have barely anything in them, others are loaded. The trouble arises here.





Custom trophies have lead to a mess, and I mean a mess, there are multiple trophies that are nothing more than stock images, some with broken texture or shitty alignment, others just don't represent the tournament.

Should we change the images of trophies, moving away from stock images and move towards custom trophies? Should we change trophies that do not represent their tournament?

YES

Change trophies to represent the tournament. Standardizing is boring though

Sure looks good.

Only if you promise to not take away those shiny, lovely, warmth needed trophies..

I believe that official atwar trophies should be standarized, while non-official tournaments should only get custom trophies if they meet a few requirements.

Tournaments should only have trophies (custom trophies), if they are 64 players or more. To maintained the trophies sense of value, other than that a standard trophy is best for 63 or under. People are making trophies for small tourneys which isn't needed and degrading the value of them by inflating the number of trophies with no value.
i.e. Underdogs Tournament - I didn't make a trophy for it in the end, but it would have been so unnecessary

लिखा द्वारा Tundy, 22.07.2016 at 11:51

I believe that official atwar trophies should be standarized, while non-official tournaments should only get custom trophies if they meet a few requirements.

...

EDIT: holy shit i got a new trophy xD

cute little bunny!!!!

It can be solved so simply:

Custom Trophies - For ended Tournaments with 32+ participants which must meet certain requirements
Standardized Trophies - For all the rest things (as writing contest, HTML5 tester, +100 CWs, etc..)

We need more trophies

लिखा द्वारा Nero, 22.07.2016 at 15:19

We need more trophies

clovis can donate to you

Am I the only one who noticed in the ss that mods can award trophies to themselves?

लिखा द्वारा Darth., 23.07.2016 at 02:21

Am I the only one who noticed in the ss that mods can award trophies to themselves?

Why wouldn't they award trophies to themselves for little or no reason? That's how clovis got 100 trophies.

To keep with things, I've added 4 new fun trophies. The old cartographer trophy got removed in exchange for 2 new standard rules trophies. The playmaker trophy is back now with a legit way to get it. A new trophy for participating in duels also added.

Gimme meester gimme!

EDIT:

लिखा द्वारा Meester, 23.07.2016 at 08:06

To keep with things, I've added 4 new fun trophies. The old cartographer trophy got removed in exchange for 2 new standard rules trophies. The playmaker trophy is back now with a legit way to get it. A new trophy for participating in duels also added.

lol the cartographer and shoeshiner images are dota2 hero abilities. Such an asian

लिखा द्वारा Meester, 23.07.2016 at 08:06

fun trophies.

Do we really have to discuss why fun trophies are such an horrendous idea?

http://atwar-game.com/forum/topic.php?topic_id=17271

EDIT: special little snowflake anyone?

EDIT #2 sorrz... guess Ive just jumped to it. Why add more fun badges though?

As for the rest of this thread I agree they shouldbe standardize( except once again, fun trophies. Rather than standardized they should be removed).

लिखा द्वारा Goblin, 23.07.2016 at 08:45

-

inb4 comeback

लिखा द्वारा Meester, 23.07.2016 at 08:06

To keep with things, I've added 4 new fun trophies. The old cartographer trophy got removed in exchange for 2 new standard rules trophies. The playmaker trophy is back now with a legit way to get it. A new trophy for participating in duels also added.

Gimme the "Gimme" trophy plox.

Also, maybe a trophy for 1k duels?

लिखा द्वारा Phoenix, 23.07.2016 at 10:53

Gimme the "Gimme" trophy plox.

Also, maybe a trophy for 1k duels?

Added. Still in the process of overhauling the current system, maybe we can see new trophies ones when we are done.

लिखा द्वारा clovis1122, 23.07.2016 at 10:40

लिखा द्वारा Goblin, 23.07.2016 at 08:45

-

...k lets not spam memes man xD

I'd go with non-standard but have to be approved by a mod for relevance and quality

also, I think play-based trophies should somehow have higher value, maybe make it a little bigger or have more space for a longer caption

When will you add a "Follower of Tik-Tok" map making badge? ;P

Purge them all

लिखा द्वारा Tundy, 23.07.2016 at 15:14

When will you add a "Follower of Tik-Tok" map making badge? ;P

I think you need something more special than that. How about...